Helping Teachers Navigate Student Disrespect

Dr Michael E. Bernard

Founder, You Can Do It! Education

Emeritus Professor, California State University, Long Beach
Former Professor, Melbourne Graduate School for Education, Melbourne University
Doctorate of Educational Psychology

As more teachers contemplate early retirement, a significant factor driving this exodus is the struggle with student disrespect. The classroom environment has become increasingly challenging, leaving many dedicated educators feeling emotionally drained by student behaviour that seems more difficult to address. Recent surveys show that nearly 40% of teachers are considering leaving the profession in the next two years, primarily due to issues related to classroom management and student behaviour.

Instead of seeing deteriorating student behaviour as something teachers must simply tolerate, we can draw on insights from cognitive psychology and brain science to help educators in developing the high levels of resilience needed to cope with students’ disrespect and maintain their passion for teaching.

Over the past few years, I’ve shared valuable strategies with teachers that focus not only on directly altering student behaviour but also on the importance of emotional regulation needed to respond calmly and constructively to difficult situations.

Understanding the Impact of Student Disrespect

Student disrespect manifests in various forms—from subtle eye-rolling and talking back to more explicit defiance and disruption. These behaviours don’t just interrupt lessons; they can also fundamentally shake a teacher’s confidence and sense of professional competence. The cumulative effect of daily challenges can lead to chronic stress, burnout, and ultimately, the decision to leave teaching altogether.

The emotional toll is particularly heavy because teaching is inherently a relationship-based profession. When those relationships feel strained or even hostile, it strikes at the heart of what many educators find meaningful about their work. Teachers often enter the profession with idealistic visions of inspiring young minds, making the reality of classroom conflict particularly disheartening.

Recognising Stress-Amplifying Thought Patterns

When confronted with disrespectful behaviour, teachers can fall if they are not mindful of thinking patterns that intensify their stress levels. Overwhelming thoughts may include the belief that “I should be able to manage student defiant behaviour and when I cannot, I have failed,” “Classroom disruptions are dreadful,” and “I cannot cope with students who persist in behaving disrespectfully.” Research from cognitive behaviour therapy indicates that while these thought patterns are common and understandable, they can turn challenging situations into unbearable ones.

While natural responses to frustrating situations, these thoughts often add an additional emotional burden beyond what the actual situation requires.

Developing More Balanced Perspectives

Teachers can benefit from recognising that, while respectful behaviour is certainly preferable and important for learning, it doesn’t necessarily follow that students must always be respectful – because that’s not how students behave some of the time. Classroom challenges do not define their worth as educators or as individuals. A shift in perspective—from “This is terrible, and I can’t cope” to “This is difficult, but I can handle it”—can significantly reduce the emotional burden.

One key lies in distinguishing between preferences and demands. Wanting respect from students is a healthy expectation, while insisting on it can lead to unnecessary stress when reality falls short. This approach does not suggest lowering standards or tolerating inappropriate behaviour but emphasises addressing challenges with flexibility and resilience.

Case Study: Sarah's Transformation

Sarah, a seventh-grade English teacher with eight years of experience, was on the verge of quitting mid-semester. Her third-period class had become increasingly disruptive, with multiple students openly defying her authority by talking during lessons and showing disrespect through their body language and tone. Sarah started to dread that class and questioned her effectiveness as an educator.

Initial Response Pattern

Sarah’s internal dialogue was dominated by stress-amplifying thoughts: “These kids have no respect for me as they should. I can’t teach like this. If I can’t control my classroom, I shouldn’t be teaching. This is hopeless.”

Applying Perspective Changing Cognitive Strategies

Working with a mentor teacher, Sarah began identifying and challenging her stress-amplifying thought patterns. She learned to recognise when her thoughts were amplifying her stress and practised reframing them.

Instead of thinking, “I can’t teach like this,” she learned to think, “This is challenging, but I have skills and resources to address it.” Rather than thinking, “These kids have no respect,” Sarah shifted to, “Some students are struggling with appropriate behaviour, and I can help them learn better choices.” And “While student disrespect is bad, it’s not the very worst thing I can experience, and I can cope.”

Practical Changes

Sarah implemented several strategies:

She set clear and consistent consequences without becoming emotionally reactive.
She began building individual relationships with challenging students outside of conflict situations.
She focused on her responses rather than trying to control student emotions.
She showed self-compassion when lessons didn’t go perfectly and her class was unruly.

Results

Within six weeks, Sarah noticed significant changes. Although student behaviour didn’t transform overnight, her stress levels decreased dramatically. She felt more confident in addressing disruptions calmly and consistently. Most importantly, she rediscovered her enjoyment of teaching and chose to remain in the profession.

The key insight was that Sarah couldn’t control every aspect of student behaviour, but she could manage her interpretation of events and her responses. This shift from feeling victimised by circumstances to feeling empowered to respond skilfully made all the difference.

Practical Coping Strategies

Effective self-talk is crucial during challenging moments. Rather than taking disrespectful behaviour personally, teachers can remind themselves that students’ actions often reflect their own struggles instead of the teacher’s shortcomings. Concentrating on controllable factors—maintaining consistent consequences, staying calm, and responding constructively—empowers teachers further.

Daily Practices

Morning Intention Setting: Begin each day by reflecting on your core purpose as an educator and your ability to face challenges.
Midday Check-ins: Pause briefly between classes to evaluate your emotional state and adjust your thinking and perspective if needed.
Evening Reflection: Reflect on challenging moments without being too hard on yourself. Focus on what you learned and how you can improve.
Weekend Planning: Develop strategies for future challenges while maintaining work-life boundaries.

In-the-Moment Techniques

Take three deep breaths before responding to disruptive behaviour.
Use internal mantras like “I can handle this” or “This doesn’t define my worth”.
Focus on the behaviour, not the student’s character.
Remember that consistency is more important than perfection.

A Rational Reminder for Teachers Facing Student Disrespect

Although the evidence supporting CBT and REBT-based programs is compelling, their effectiveness ultimately depends on the quality of implementation. Based on research and practical experience, several best practices emerge for schools aiming to establish preventative mental health programs:

Situation	Stress-Amplifying Thought	Table Balanced Response
Check Your Beliefs	“I can’t teach if students don’t respect me!”	“I want respect, but I can function well without it.”
Don’t Catastrophize	“Their behaviour is horrible — I can’t do this!”	“It’s difficult and unpleasant — but I can handle it.”
Use Coping Self-Talk	“I’m a terrible teacher if I can’t control my class.”	“This is frustrating, but I’m still in control of my response.”
Address Worth	“Their disrespect means I’m a failure.”	“Their behaviour doesn’t define my worth as a teacher.”
Accept Reality	“Students should never act this way.”	“Students will misbehave — that’s a fact of life I can deal with.”
Focus Control	“Nothing I do makes a difference.”	“I can stay calm, be consistent, and avoid taking it personally.”
Self-Acceptance	“I should be able to handle everything perfectly.”	“Even if I make mistakes, I’m still a worthwhile person and teacher.”
Student Acceptance	“These kids are just bad.”	“These students are not all bad because they misbehave, they’re still developing humans.”

Moving Forward with Confidence

By shifting the focus from what students should do to how teachers can respond skilfully, you can regain any lost sense of professional efficacy and rediscover the joy in teaching that originally drew you to education. This approach doesn’t diminish the real challenges of student disrespect or suggest that respectful behaviour from students isn’t necessary. Instead, it provides a path forward that empowers you to thrive, even in the face of difficult circumstances.

The objective isn’t to eliminate all stress or frustration—these feelings are natural responses to difficult situations. Instead, the aim is to prevent these common emotions from becoming overwhelming and harmful. When you feel confident to be able to cope emotionally and manage any challenges that arise, you are more likely to remain in the profession and continue making the positive impact that initially attracted you to teaching.

Remember: You became a teacher to make a difference, and challenging moments don’t diminish your ability to do just that. With the right strategies and mindset, you can weather any storm and continue the essential work of educating the next generation.

E2. The Resilient Educator Professional Development eLearning Course

10. Stress Management for Teachers and Principals: A Professional Development Program

Embracing your authentic self. Photo by Brooke Cagle on Unsplash.

Embracing Your Authentic Self. A Path to Inner Power

9 minute read Best practices to create a more enjoyable and less stressful workplace experience There is no better ticket to getting off life’s rollercoaster ...